The Parish Council at the meeting held on Monday 15th June 2026 resolved to submit the below comment to the planning inspectorate in respect of the following planning application.
| Reference | 25/2977/OUT 6009169 | Deadline | 18th June 2026 |
| Type of Application | Appeal | ||
| Location | Land Off Broad Lane, Nantwich, CW5 7QL | ||
| Proposal | Outline planning application for the demolition of number 6 Broad Lane and a residential development comprising up to 75no. dwellings together with parking, open space, landscaping, drainage and associated works. All matters reserved except for means of access | ||
| Cheshire East | pa.cheshireeast.gov.uk | Application | 401534 | |||
Notwithstanding the refusal decision by Cheshire East Council, which we support, the Council brings the following points to the planning inspectorate’s attention.
The key arguments for dismissing this appeal relate to that of a previous appeals inspector who deemed that this road was unsafe and without capacity for a development in 2015 for 104 homes. This still stands. This development did not take place and was replaced by a smaller one known as Halfpenny Close.
This was incorrectly referred to by the Planning Officer at a meeting of the Strategic Planning Board on 25th March 2026 at which this development was considered where the officer confused the comments on the original application for 104 houses as relating to the Halfpenny Close development.
This road has already suffered the addition of the homes off Halfpenny Close and so is now more dangerous and has even less capacity than when the appeals planning inspector originally made her comments.
In response to the evidence given in 2.8, there are significant differences. This development is on the other side of Stapeley and would not touch the Audlem Road / Broad Lane (which functions as a residential street – that has already had an increase of traffic since this was stated) and whilst it will greatly impact the roads, it is not deemed to be as dangerous as this proposal.
Statement 2.10 states “The agreed extension date of the 26 March remains intact and importantly; no interested party would have been prejudiced by a decision at that Committee”. This is immaterial as the consultation closing date had already been published.
2.12 – the reason for the demands for the cumulative traffic assessment was to ascertain the safety of the roads. The safety of the roads is absolutely a material consideration for the postponement of any decision.
3.20 – We fail to understand why a decision could be made that a traffic assessment is not needed for ALL developments under 80 homes. This does not take into consideration any other developments that have already taken place in the area which may be numerous, or which may have impacted an already dangerous and ‘at capacity’ road such as this one; as determined by an appeals planning inspector before the construction of Halfpenny Close which exits onto the same road.
4.7 has misunderstood the point of the policy H1 from the Stapeley and Batherton Neighbourhood Plan in that the policy seeks to only allow infill and brownfield sites, and only where they have been exhausted, will it look to then recommend development within or adjacent to the settlement boundary. The fact that the Neighbourhood Plan is more than 5 years old does not discount this as a legal planning document to be upheld.
4.8 of our Neighbourhood Plan requires that such developments should have provided a full traffic assessment, and a full Travel Plan in accordance with policy T1. We know that any development along that road will have a significant impact, based on the previous planning appeal inspector’s comments for a development impacting the same road. This road is already in a worse situation now that the Halfpenny Close development has been built (43 houses).
4.9 states that “Policy T2 (Pedestrian and Cycle Routes), also seeks to create and support walkable and cyclable neighbourhoods (T2a) and routes to services such as the town centre and schools (T2b). Policy T4 (Bus Stops) seeks bus stops provided as part of a development to be of an appropriate design, and “all weather” providing real time information where appropriate.” It is clear that there are no linkable cycleways in the area, the footpath that the developers propose to link to is only passable in good weather and indeed runs through a water-logged field. There is a substandard footpath only on the opposite side to the primary school along Broad Lane onto which the proposed development would exit.
4.16, 4.17 and 4.18 – Despite the statement made about statistics saying that there is a shortfall in housing numbers, we are aware that properties that are not selling in our area, some which have been on the market for years. Indeed, the new development off Peter de Stapleigh Way (which meets Broad Lane at a controlled junction) that is currently underway is not selling at anywhere near the rates first anticipated. The five-year land supply and housing supply should NOT undermine the safety of the people who live along this road, nor those who use it to walk to school, or the farmers who rely on this road for their livelihood.
5.17 This traffic impact statement is based on 2030 levels without the inclusion of significant developments that are already underway and the only high school in this area is directly adjacent to those traffic lights, so the cited increases of 2.9% and 2.6% are wildly underestimated. Similarly, we know that statistically we have more cars per head in this area (as shown by the Office for National Statistics) and that the average number of journeys per day can be double in this area.
5.24 – it is the impact of the developments that are currently underway and have already been granted full planning permission that we seek to understand with a cumulative traffic assessment as it is from this that the base readings should then be taken, for all future development. This has not yet been done, nor is this traffic statement based on these new certain levels.
5.40 – as stated earlier, the fact that the traffic assessment is based on an historical picture of the roads, and not a true representation of the current traffic situation (or immediate future traffic situation once all current developments are completed) is a case for a new and cumulative traffic assessment. We are not simply stating that this must be done because other developments are pending, we are stating that this is a vital requirement because of all of the developments that are currently underway for this to then be used as a benchmark for any future and pending developments. We cannot ignore what is under development/granted but not yet completed. We are extremely concerned about local traffic levels, from two points of view, highway and pedestrian safety and congestion.
5.45 – as stated earlier, this footpath is over waterlogged fields and is only passable without wellington boots for around 3 months every year. This is not a sustainable footpath.
5.47 – there are no cyclable routes from this development and no link up with any cycle-routes. The ‘walkable’ routes are largely waterlogged, or along inadequate, below required width and unsafe pavements. These cannot be considered in compliance with policy T2 of the Stapeley and Batherton Neighbourhood Plan. It is also baffling how unused bus stops are being considered as ‘in service’ in this appeal The Council Officers erroneously cited at the Strategic Planning Board on 26th March 2026 that considered this application that the previous appeal planning inspector’s comments weren’t relevant here as they related to the Halfpenny Close development which has already been finalised. The comments were for another development on the adjacent field to this application/appeal and are therefore wholly relevant. The appellant maintains the assertion that the planning officers had no objections, but we would challenge that this to be the case when they were acting under misguided and erroneous information. To be clear, this development would not constitute a Sustainable Development and therefore should not be considered in that light and is indeed subject to all of the due diligence detailed above.
7.11 and 7.12 – to be clear, the fact that the Stapeley and Batherton Neighbourhood Plan does not allocate sites is neither here nor there. There is no legal or statutory requirement for a Neighbourhood Plan to include the allocation of sites. We have demonstrated a housing supply, indeed whilst our plan may be 8 years old, that does not make it any less relevant, nor give developers the right to ignore our policies as it is still – legally speaking – a valid planning document. As there has been major, consistent development throughout the entirety of the 8 years that the plan has been in existence, one can demonstrate that we have delivered over and above our allocation of homes as the Local Plan itself detailed that we had delivered our housing supply.
7.14 – This is simply not the case and the impact on the highways would be significant for all of the reasons stated above. There is also limited access to the site by any means other than vehicular access as the pavements are sub-standard, the footpath is largely flooded and muddy and there are no cycle routes.
7.17 – bullet point 3 – the ‘benefit’ of providing green spaces when an agricultural field is being sacrificed for the development does not bear scrutiny.
7.18 – This statement is incorrect. The only reason that ponds exist in this area is due to local flooding and the water table being overwhelmed.
7.22 – The application mentioned here (David Wilson Homes) is on a road that has a footpath on one side that is of adequate width and which is directly opposite a cycle path and is much closer to the main bypass than this proposed development. The traffic impact of the David Wilson Homes development is likely to be significantly less than this application from which all traffic will have to pass at least one school, more likely two.
Appendix 1 – We are disappointed to see that the transcript of the objectors’ statements – including that of Stapeley and District Parish Council – and our answers to members’ questions, has been left out of the appeals transcript as this was a ‘relevant section’ of the Strategic Planning Board meeting and is materially relevant to this appeal.
We are not unsupportive of development, we are unsupportive of developments that will harm our area, and this is one such example. The proposed site is greenfield and is used to grow crops, one of the few left in our Parish thanks to continued building and this resource should be protected. The dangers that this application and appeal pose to Audlem Road/Broad Lane and the surrounding area are staggering as identified by Councillors, local residents and a fully qualified appeals planning inspector in 2016. We live in the Parish and represent the people who live, walk, work in, and care for this area and we are trying to ask that the proper assessments are undertaken rather than a decision being made from afar.
It is our opinion that the policy conflicts and the adverse impacts on the locality identified would ‘significantly and demonstrably’ outweigh the benefits of the proposal for both our local highway network, the impact on local residents and road users, and our ecological and arable landscape.